Myths about reinforcement
Posted: Sun Dec 22, 2024 9:58 am
To be successful in any business, it is very important to maintain a life balance, find time for rest and celebrate significant dates. For example, employees of the SILKO design bureau recently celebrated the company's 25th anniversary in nature. A rich active holiday helped them recover and return with renewed vigor to responsible and complex tasks, such as 3D modeling of reinforcement.
Valeria Poryvkina, the bureau’s leading designer and BIM coordinator, spoke about SILKO’s experience in this area saudi arabia phone number at the July BIM breakfast, dispelling several myths that the designers encountered along the way.
Over the past 25 years, SILKO has implemented a wide variety of projects, including both public buildings and residential complexes. For example, the Industrial Progress Center in the small town of Vyksa in the Nizhny Novgorod Region, which is called the "temple of metal." Or the buildings of ITMO University and IT University in Nizhny Novgorod, located in the very center of the city. Also among the bureau's projects, the Parusnaya residential complex in St. Petersburg stands out, which is well known to city residents as an area for walking.
When looking at this gallery of successful projects, the question naturally arises: how to model reinforcement for such non-standard projects? Before delving into the details, Valeria Poryvkina decided to dispel some myths that often appeared at the stage of working with reinforcement.
Files with reinforcement are too heavy
In fact, modern software allows you to create fairly lightweight files. For example, the file of the project of the NIC N.A. Almazov with complex geometry and radius walls weighs only 184 MB
All reinforcement in the project must be modeled
This is not always the case. In SILCO, reinforcement is modeled only in unique designs, which significantly simplifies the work and reduces the file size. Typical designs are reinforced individually once
Modeling reinforcement on complex objects does not work
This myth is also wrong. According to the BIM coordinator, the bureau successfully used BIM even on complex objects with unique geometry. Modern software tools really do allow modeling reinforcement in objects of any complexity
Why not use IFC reinforcement?
At the initial stages of work, SILKO considered using IFC reinforcement: the already created families could be easily used in work. However, everything turned out to be not so simple, and the bureau encountered a number of problems.
Reduced productivity: Model files started to take up a lot of space and slow down a lot. It was necessary for all designers to be able to work together in a comfortable mode
Lack of automatic base labeling: this made it difficult to determine the element's ownership and collect specifications
No consideration of reinforcement spacing: Some projects required a reduction in reinforcement spacing that could not be achieved using IFC
Complex composite specifications: the creation and verification of such specifications required constant monitoring by a BIM specialist
Why reinforce in Revit?
In favor of reinforcement modeling in Revit, the expert named the following key advantages:
Data relevance: all project information is contained in one file, which eliminates data loss
Automatic reinforcement creation: although there is no full automation yet, using plugins significantly speeds up the process
Automatic generation of specifications: with the correct settings of filters and templates, specifications are generated almost automatically
Visual inspection: At the design stage, the designer can easily check where there is not enough reinforcement and where there is too much.
Selecting Plugins for Automation
SILKO assembled a working group of specialists of different levels to select a plug-in for modeling automation. As a result, they identified four plug-ins: Future BIM, ModPlus, BIM‑STARTER and CITRUS. Among the selection criteria, the lead designer noted:
Functionality: It was important that the plugin supported reinforcing walls with frames, as well as reinforcing stairs, columns, ceilings, frogs, etc.
Interface: The simplicity and clarity of the interface also played a big role, as these qualities allowed new people to be quickly trained to work with new tools.
Compatibility with ADSK templates: many customers use ADSK templates in their work, so integration with them was an important criterion
Price: Since the plugin needed to be installed on many computers, it was necessary to find an option with the most affordable price
In the end, BIM specialists settled on Future BIM , which met the largest number of the requirements presented.
Future BIM in practice
With permission from the plugin developer, Valeria Poryvkina shared several key features of the Future BIM plugin that she actively used with her team:
Reinforcement of walls and floors: the plugin tools allow you to select slabs and place reinforcement in them, as well as set up automatic creation of specifications
Wall frames: you can install a frame with extensions in the overlying walls and further optimize the modeling process
Frogs and supporting frames: Future BIM allows automatic placement of frogs and frames of different types (herringbone, pyramid, straight vertical) with a number parameter, which significantly saves modeling time
Reinforcement of stairs: this function became a real salvation for the expert, allowing him to quickly and effectively reinforce monolithic flights
Conclusion
With the right tools, modeling reinforcement in Revit becomes quite easy. The experience of SILKO designers has shown that purchasing the plug-in is completely justified. Time and financial costs for modeling are reduced several times, and the opening of such important projects as a university building or a residential complex is approaching ever faster, which pleases both customers and those who will operate them.
Valeria Poryvkina, the bureau’s leading designer and BIM coordinator, spoke about SILKO’s experience in this area saudi arabia phone number at the July BIM breakfast, dispelling several myths that the designers encountered along the way.
Over the past 25 years, SILKO has implemented a wide variety of projects, including both public buildings and residential complexes. For example, the Industrial Progress Center in the small town of Vyksa in the Nizhny Novgorod Region, which is called the "temple of metal." Or the buildings of ITMO University and IT University in Nizhny Novgorod, located in the very center of the city. Also among the bureau's projects, the Parusnaya residential complex in St. Petersburg stands out, which is well known to city residents as an area for walking.
When looking at this gallery of successful projects, the question naturally arises: how to model reinforcement for such non-standard projects? Before delving into the details, Valeria Poryvkina decided to dispel some myths that often appeared at the stage of working with reinforcement.
Files with reinforcement are too heavy
In fact, modern software allows you to create fairly lightweight files. For example, the file of the project of the NIC N.A. Almazov with complex geometry and radius walls weighs only 184 MB
All reinforcement in the project must be modeled
This is not always the case. In SILCO, reinforcement is modeled only in unique designs, which significantly simplifies the work and reduces the file size. Typical designs are reinforced individually once
Modeling reinforcement on complex objects does not work
This myth is also wrong. According to the BIM coordinator, the bureau successfully used BIM even on complex objects with unique geometry. Modern software tools really do allow modeling reinforcement in objects of any complexity
Why not use IFC reinforcement?
At the initial stages of work, SILKO considered using IFC reinforcement: the already created families could be easily used in work. However, everything turned out to be not so simple, and the bureau encountered a number of problems.
Reduced productivity: Model files started to take up a lot of space and slow down a lot. It was necessary for all designers to be able to work together in a comfortable mode
Lack of automatic base labeling: this made it difficult to determine the element's ownership and collect specifications
No consideration of reinforcement spacing: Some projects required a reduction in reinforcement spacing that could not be achieved using IFC
Complex composite specifications: the creation and verification of such specifications required constant monitoring by a BIM specialist
Why reinforce in Revit?
In favor of reinforcement modeling in Revit, the expert named the following key advantages:
Data relevance: all project information is contained in one file, which eliminates data loss
Automatic reinforcement creation: although there is no full automation yet, using plugins significantly speeds up the process
Automatic generation of specifications: with the correct settings of filters and templates, specifications are generated almost automatically
Visual inspection: At the design stage, the designer can easily check where there is not enough reinforcement and where there is too much.
Selecting Plugins for Automation
SILKO assembled a working group of specialists of different levels to select a plug-in for modeling automation. As a result, they identified four plug-ins: Future BIM, ModPlus, BIM‑STARTER and CITRUS. Among the selection criteria, the lead designer noted:
Functionality: It was important that the plugin supported reinforcing walls with frames, as well as reinforcing stairs, columns, ceilings, frogs, etc.
Interface: The simplicity and clarity of the interface also played a big role, as these qualities allowed new people to be quickly trained to work with new tools.
Compatibility with ADSK templates: many customers use ADSK templates in their work, so integration with them was an important criterion
Price: Since the plugin needed to be installed on many computers, it was necessary to find an option with the most affordable price
In the end, BIM specialists settled on Future BIM , which met the largest number of the requirements presented.
Future BIM in practice
With permission from the plugin developer, Valeria Poryvkina shared several key features of the Future BIM plugin that she actively used with her team:
Reinforcement of walls and floors: the plugin tools allow you to select slabs and place reinforcement in them, as well as set up automatic creation of specifications
Wall frames: you can install a frame with extensions in the overlying walls and further optimize the modeling process
Frogs and supporting frames: Future BIM allows automatic placement of frogs and frames of different types (herringbone, pyramid, straight vertical) with a number parameter, which significantly saves modeling time
Reinforcement of stairs: this function became a real salvation for the expert, allowing him to quickly and effectively reinforce monolithic flights
Conclusion
With the right tools, modeling reinforcement in Revit becomes quite easy. The experience of SILKO designers has shown that purchasing the plug-in is completely justified. Time and financial costs for modeling are reduced several times, and the opening of such important projects as a university building or a residential complex is approaching ever faster, which pleases both customers and those who will operate them.